THE PROBLEM
I recently sent out an email to several friends and family members, asking them three questions:
- Do you like Bert or Ernie better?
- Why?
- How old are Ernie & Bert?
I thought that my blog would be an ideal medium for “publishing” the results of this little, informal survey.
But first, some background. For the last few months, I’ve been living with my sister while I figure out a more permanent place to live. About a week ago, she asked me whether I liked Bert or Ernie better. Her 4-year-old daughter had been watching Sesame Street and informed her mother (my sister) that “Ernie is always mean to Bert.” My sister was shocked by this response to the duo, and wanted to know what I thought about them; then, she wanted to know how old I thought they were. We disagreed on both points, and that sparked a friendly debate between us, in which her 14-year-old daughter soon joined. So I decided to take more decisive action.
By the way, my sister likes Ernie better, and I like Bert better. (It had never even occurred to her that some people might like Bert better, until her 4-year-old daughter brought it up.) She thinks that they are both around 6 or 7, and I think they are grown-ups, in their 20s or 30s.
THE RESULTS
So, here are the answers I got (including mine and my sister’s):
1. Do you like Bert or Ernie better?
Bert: 4
Ernie: 8
2. Why?
Bert: Bert is more responsible, level-headed, and sensible. Ernie is annoying; he moves in on Bert’s territory and doesn’t even seem to think about Bert’s feelings; he’s insensitive.
Ernie: Ernie is fun-loving and outgoing, likes to laugh and joke; he is creative and casual. Bert is too serious and stiff; he doesn’t see the fun side of life, he has boring hobbies (collecting bottle-caps, talking to pigeons), and he’s always bugging Ernie to grow up. Also, Bert is the “classic straight man” (which I completely agree with), which means you’re not supposed to like him as much (which I completely disagree with; does that mean that I’m not supposed to like Bud Abbott or George Burns? ‘Cuz I do!).
3. How old are Ernie & Bert?
4-12: 2
teens (13-19): 1
20s – 30s: 5
40s or older: 1
neither old nor young: 1
(P.S. Yes, I know that all the numbers don’t quite add up; that’s because some people had more than one opinion on one of the questions, and others didn’t answer one.)
THE CONCLUSION
Well, it appears that Ernie is generally more popular (although I found it very interesting to note that my closest friends preferred Bert, as do I). Likewise, the general consensus is that they are in their 20s to 30s–but there is certainly room for doubt!
So, now I turn the question over to the rest of you out there. Whom do you prefer, and why? What age do you think Ernie & Bert are?
